Giving and receiving feedback is probably one of life’s greatest challenges both personally and professionally. As leaders, it is critical to continually develop our capacity for both giving and receiving feedback, both positive and negative. Most would agree that giving or receiving positive feedback is relatively simple in comparison to giving or receiving negative feedback. In reality though, negative feedback (the stuff we’re not doing or we need to do better), is essential if we are to learn and grow, and how we behave in the face of feedback is where the learning must begin.
Executive coach and author Marshall Goldsmith describes people’s usual reaction to positive and negative feedback this way. He says that we all tend to accept feedback that is compatible to what we believe to be true, and we tend to ‘reject’ feedback that does not match our sense of reality. This concept is akin to pattern recognition or “cognitive dissonance” – that is, our brains gravitate toward information that is known, familiar or concrete. It seems then, that how we react or behave to feedback is in part biological.
For example, if an executive receives feedback that she is a poor listener she may become defensive and deem the comment an insult. After all, she may argue, she did not rise to her current position by not paying attention to others’ needs and wants along the way. Thus, she will ignore the feedback altogether, rendering the process a waste of time and effort. This example could apply to all levels of employees in all kinds of jobs.
Developing a self-awareness that recognizes our innate behavioural tendencies, falls within our skill level of Positive Presence. If you have a new consciousness of your skill of Positive Presence, it’s more than worth taking a closer look into.
